Blockk Blockk Blockk Blockk
  • News Portal
  • World Desk
    • Sign In
    • Submit Content
    • Register
  • All Content
    • Edited
      • Topics
        • Agriculture
        • Culture
          • Arts
          • Children
          • Education
          • Entertainment
          • Food and Hunger
          • Sports
        • Disasters
        • Economy
        • Energy
        • Environment
        • Government
        • Health
        • Media
        • Science
        • Spiritual
        • Technology
        • Transportation
        • War
      • Regions
        • Africa
        • Americas
          • North America
          • South America
        • Antarctica
        • Arctic
        • Asia
        • Australia/Oceania
        • Europe
        • Middle East
        • Oceans
          • Arctic Ocean
          • Atlantic Ocean
          • Indian Ocean
          • Pacific Ocean
          • Southern Ocean
        • Space
      • News
      • Commentary
      • Analysis
      • Advisories
      • Source
    • Flatwire
  • About Us
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us

Latest Stories

... loading images
GOOD MORNING! 230928
GOOD MORNING! 230928
Artificial intelligence (AI) | Wikipedia
Artificial intelligence (AI) | Wikipedia
Blockchain | Wikipedia
Blockchain | Wikipedia
NASA's First Asteroid Samples Land On Earth After Release ...
NASA's First Asteroid Samples Land On Earth After Release From Spacecraft | Marcia Dunn
Our Digital Twins Will Help Diagnose And Treat Diseases ...
Our Digital Twins Will Help Diagnose And Treat Diseases | Thomas Gull, University of Zurich
US Farmers, Tech Tycoons Square Off Over Plans For Utopian ...
US Farmers, Tech Tycoons Square Off Over Plans For Utopian City | Glenn Chapman
Falling Solar Power And Storage Prices Make Global Climate ...
Falling Solar Power And Storage Prices Make Global Climate Transition Cheaper Than Expected | Ulrich von Lampe
Why the Next Crypto Bull Run Will Be Like Nothing We've ...
Why the Next Crypto Bull Run Will Be Like Nothing We've Ever Experienced | Solo Ceesay
Human-Driven Mass Extinction Is Eliminating Entire Branches ...
Human-Driven Mass Extinction Is Eliminating Entire Branches Of The Tree Of Life | Stanford University
The Untold Story of the Abuse of Palestinian Women in ...
The Untold Story of the Abuse of Palestinian Women in Hebron | Ramzy Baroud
‘Bread and Circuses’: Musk, Zuckerberg and the Art of ...
‘Bread and Circuses’: Musk, Zuckerberg and the Art of Distraction | Ramzy Baroud
What Are Smart Contracts? | Bing
What Are Smart Contracts? | Bing
Climate Conflagration: Maui to Montana | Amy Goodman & ...
Climate Conflagration: Maui to Montana | Amy Goodman & Denis Moynihan
Best Way To Enter News Stories Into A Blockchain? | Bing
Best Way To Enter News Stories Into A Blockchain? | Bing
War By Other Means: Short-Selling JPMorgan | Ellen Brown
War By Other Means: Short-Selling JPMorgan | Ellen Brown
Israel’s Slippery Slope | Nouriel Roubini
Israel’s Slippery Slope | Nouriel Roubini

Imagining Palestine: On Barghouti, Darwish, Kanafani and the Language of Exile | Ramzy Baroud

More items by author
Categories
Edited | Courts | Law | Government | Education | All Content | Front Page Stories | Commentary | Middle East | North America | War | Books | Politics | Commentary -- WNT Reports | Analysis
Tool Bar
View Comments

Dr. Ramzy BaroudDr. Ramzy BaroudRamzy Baroud -- World News Trust

Feb. 21, 2021

 

For Palestinians, exile is not simply the physical act of being removed from their homes and their inability to return.

 

It is not a casual topic pertaining to politics and international law, either. Nor is it an ethereal notion, a sentiment, a poetic verse. It is all of this, combined.

 

The death in Amman of Palestinian poet, Mourid Barghouti, an intellectual whose work has intrinsically been linked to exile, brought back to the surface many existential questions: are Palestinians destined to be exiled? Can there be a remedy for this perpetual torment? Is justice a tangible, achievable goal?

 

Barghouti was born in 1944 in Deir Ghassana, near Ramallah. His journey in exile began in 1967, and ended, however temporarily, 30 years later. His memoir “I Saw Ramallah” -- published in 1997 -- was an exiled man’s attempt to make sense of his identity, one that has been formulated within many different physical spaces, conflicts and airports. While, in some way, the Palestinian in Barghouti remained intact, his was a unique identity that can only be fathomed by those who have experienced, to some degree, the pressing feelings of Ghurba (estrangement and alienation)  or Shataat (dislocation and diaspora).

 

In his memoir, translated into English in 2000 by acclaimed Egyptian author, Ahdaf Soueif, he wrote, “I tried to put the displacement between parenthesis, to put a last period in a long sentence of the sadness of history ... But I see nothing except commas. I want to sew the times together. I want to attach one moment to another, to attach childhood to age, to attach the present to the absent and all the presents to all absences, attach exiles to the homeland and to attach what I have imagined to what I see now.”

 

Those familiar with the rich and complex Palestinian literature of exile can relate Barghouti’s reference -- what one imagines versus what one sees -- to the writing of other intellectuals who have suffered the pain of exile as well. Ghassan Kanafani and Majed Abu Sharar -- and numerous others -- wrote about that same conflict. Their death -- or, rather, assassination -- in exile brought their philosophical journeys to an abrupt end.

 

In Mahmoud Darwish’s seminal poem, Who Am I, Without Exile, the late Palestinian poet asked, knowing that there can never be a compelling answer: “What will we do without exile?”

 

It is as if Ghurba has been so integral to the collective character of a nation, and is now a permanent tattoo on the heart and soul of the Palestinian people everywhere. “A stranger on the riverbank, like the river ... water binds me to your name. Nothing brings me back from my faraway to my palm tree: not peace and not war. Nothing makes me enter the gospels. Not a thing,” Darwish wrote.

 

The impossibility of becoming a whole again in Darwish and Barghouti’s verses were reverberations of Kanafani’s own depiction of a Palestine that was as agonizingly near as it was far.

 

“What is a homeland?” Kanafani asks in Returning to Haifa. “Is it these two chairs that remained in this room for 20 years? The table? Peacock feathers? The picture of Jerusalem on the wall? The copper-lock? The oak tree? The balcony? What is a homeland? ... I'm only asking.”

 

But there can be no answers, because when exile exceeds a certain rational point of waiting for some kind of justice that would facilitate one’s return, it can no longer be articulated, relayed or even fully comprehended. It is the metaphorical precipice between life and death, "life" as in the burning desire to be reunited with one’s previous self, and "death" as in knowing that without a homeland one is a perpetual outcast -- physically, politically, legally, intellectually and every other form.

 

“In my despair I remember; that there is life after death … But I ask: Oh my God, is there life before death?” Barghouti wrote in his poem I Have No Problem.

 

While the crushing weight of exile is not unique to Palestinians, the Palestinian exile is unique. Throughout the entire episode of Palestinian Ghurba, from the early days of the Nakba -- the destruction of the Palestinian homeland -- till today, the world remains divided between inaction, obliviousness, and refusal to even acknowledge the injustice that has befallen the Palestinian people.

 

Despite or, perhaps, because of his decades-long exile, Barghouti did not engage in ineffectual discussions about the rightful owners of Palestine "because we did not lose Palestine to a debate, we lost it to force.”

 

He wrote in his memoir “When we were Palestine, we were not afraid of the Jews. We did not hate them, we did not make an enemy of them. Europe of the Middle Ages hated them, but not us. Ferdinand and Isabella hated them, but not us. Hitler hated them, but not us. But when they took our entire space and exiled us from it they put both us and themselves outside the law of equality."

 

In fact, "hate" rarely factors in the work of Barghouti -- or Darwish, Kanafani, Abu Sharar and many others -- because the pain of exile, so powerful, so omnipresent, required one to re-evaluate his relationship to the homeland through emotional rapport that can only be sustained through positive energy, of love, of deep sadness, of longing.

 

“Palestine is something worthy of a man bearing arms for, dying for,” wrote Kanafani. “For us, for you and me, it’s only a search for something buried beneath the dust of memories. And look what we found beneath that dust. Yet more dust. We were mistaken when we thought the homeland was only the past.”

 

Millions of Palestinians continue to live in exile, generation after generation, painstakingly negotiating their individual and collective identities, neither able to return, nor feeling truly whole. These millions deserve to exercise their Right of Return, for their voices to be heard and to be included.

 

But even when Palestinians are able to end their physical exile, chances are, for generations they will remain attached to it. “I don’t know what I want. Exile is so strong within me, I may bring it to the land,” wrote Darwish.

 

In Barghouti too, exile was "so strong." Despite the fact that he fought to end it, it became him. It became us.

 

- Ramzy Baroud is a journalist and the Editor of The Palestine Chronicle. He is the author of five books. His latest is “These Chains Will Be Broken: Palestinian Stories of Struggle and Defiance in Israeli Prisons” (Clarity Press). Dr. Baroud is a Non-resident Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Islam and Global Affairs (CIGA) and also at the Afro-Middle East Center (AMEC). His website is www.ramzybaroud.net

back to top
  • Created
    Wednesday, February 24, 2021
  • Last modified
    Sunday, March 07, 2021

World Desk Activities

  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial -- Blockchain & Crypto 28/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.coindesk.com/policy/2023/09/27/secs-gensler-th…

SEC’s Gensler Throws Crypto Punches, Dodges Bitcoin ETF Query in Congressional Hearing
SEC’s Gensler Throws Crypto Punches, Dodges Bitcoin ETF Query in Congressional Hearing Gary Gensler, while avoiding answers on bitcoin ETFs, argues in testimony that crypto firms dangerously mix assets in a way outlawed in other corners of… www.coindesk.com/policy/2023/09/27/secs-gensler-throws-more-crypto-punches-in-congressional-hearing/
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin 28/09/2023
  • Report
 

phys.org/news/2023-09-antimatter-embraces-earth-fa…

thumbnail

Antimatter embraces Earth, falling downward like normal matter: Study reveals gravity's effect on matter's elusive twin

  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial -- Blockchain & Crypto 28/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/09/27/sam…

Sam Bankman-Fried’s Biggest Grift? His ‘Best In Class’ Exchange
Sam Bankman-Fried’s Biggest Grift? His ‘Best In Class’ Exchange Never mind the alleged fraud. The centerpiece of the FTX empire – the exchange – really wasn’t that good, traders say. www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/09/27/sam-bankman-frieds-biggest-grift-his-best-in-class-exchange/
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial 28/09/2023
  • Report
 

These are 'reliable, unbiased and diverse news sources," according to Bing. -Francis

Finding reliable, unbiased and diverse news sources can be...
These are 'reliable, unbiased and diverse news sources," according to Bing. -Francis

Finding reliable, unbiased and diverse news sources can be challenging in the era of information overload and media polarization. However, there are some criteria that can help us evaluate the quality and credibility of different news outlets. Some of these criteria are:

- Transparency: A reliable news source should disclose its ownership, funding, editorial policy, sources, corrections and contact information. It should also acknowledge its biases and perspectives, if any, and avoid conflicts of interest or hidden agendas.
- Accuracy: A reliable news source should verify its facts and data before publishing or broadcasting them. It should also correct any errors or mistakes promptly and prominently. It should not distort, omit or fabricate information to fit a certain narrative or agenda.
- Diversity: A reliable news source should represent a variety of voices, opinions and perspectives on different issues and topics. It should not exclude or marginalize any groups or viewpoints based on their identity, ideology or affiliation. It should also seek to cover a wide range of topics and regions, not just those that are popular or profitable.
- Accountability: A reliable news source should be accountable to its audience and the public interest. It should follow ethical and professional standards of journalism, such as fairness, balance, objectivity and independence. It should also respond to feedback, criticism and complaints from its readers, viewers or listeners.

Based on these criteria, some examples of reliable, unbiased and diverse news sources are:

- Associated Press (AP): AP is a global news agency that provides factual and comprehensive coverage of breaking news and current events from around the world. It is owned by its member newspapers and broadcasters, and operates independently from any government or corporate influence. It has a reputation for accuracy, impartiality and speed.
- Reuters: Reuters is another global news agency that delivers fast and accurate reporting on business, finance, politics, sports and entertainment. It is owned by Thomson Reuters Corporation, a multinational media company that adheres to a Trust Principles document that ensures its editorial independence and integrity. It has a diverse team of journalists and correspondents in over 200 locations worldwide.
- BBC: BBC is a public service broadcaster that provides news, information and entertainment across television, radio, online and mobile platforms. It is funded by a license fee paid by UK households, and governed by a Royal Charter that guarantees its editorial freedom and public accountability. It has a global reach and a commitment to impartiality, accuracy and diversity.
- NPR: NPR is a non-profit media organization that produces and distributes news, talk and cultural programming for radio stations across the US. It is funded by donations from listeners, sponsors and foundations, as well as some federal funds. It has a code of ethics that guides its journalism practices and values. It has a diverse staff and audience, and covers a broad spectrum of topics and issues.
- The Guardian: The Guardian is a British newspaper that publishes online and in print editions for the UK, US and Australia. It is owned by the Scott Trust Limited, a charitable foundation that ensures its editorial independence and financial sustainability. It has a progressive outlook and a reputation for investigative journalism and social justice. It has a diverse range of contributors and opinions, as well as an international perspective.
Show more

  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial 27/09/2023
  • Report
 

reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/selection-readi…

A selection of readings on journalism - for journalists | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism
A selection of readings on journalism - for journalists | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism The Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at the University of Oxford runs a mid-career Fellowship Programme for journalists from all over the world. reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/selection-readings-journalism-journalists
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin posted a new discussion27/09/2023
  • Report

World News Trust Project Charter -- DRAFT -- Bing

DRAFT -- generated by Bing Sept. 27, 2023 Project charter for World News Trust social news network World News Trust (WNT) is a social news network...

World News Trust Project
  • Report
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin ▶ Editorial -- Artificial Intelligence 27/09/2023
  • Report
 

techxplore.com/news/2023-09-chatgpt-maker-rockets-…

ChatGPT maker value rockets in funding talks: report
ChatGPT maker value rockets in funding talks: report techxplore.com/news/2023-09-chatgpt-maker-rockets-funding.html
Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin 26/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/climate-finan…

thumbnail

What Climate Finance Needs by Nouriel Roubini & Reza Bundy - Project Syndicate

Nouriel Roubini & Reza Bundy explain what it will take to channel private capital and savings toward sustainable development.

Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin 26/09/2023
  • Report
 

www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/us-china-prev…

thumbnail

Preventing a US-China War by Nouriel Roubini - Project Syndicate

Nouriel Roubini urges both sides to pursue a new strategic understanding on the issues driving their current conflict.

Francis M Goodwin
Francis M Goodwin 25/09/2023
  • Report
 

phys.org/news/2023-09-qa-extreme-weather-impacts-f…

thumbnail

Q&A: How extreme weather impacts fall foliage

blue-flag-thumb2_50x50Our side's flag is a thin, airlight blue, drifting almost unseen against the sky. Our military march is a meadowlark's song among the dandelions.
--Ken Kesey, The Real War 
 
Welcome to the World News Trust social news network. We are dedicated to your privacy and the highest standards of journalistic excellence. Help us build a great news service. Visit our World Desk community to register or log in. See you there.
 
 -Francis Goodwin, World News Trust founder

Community Videos

  • David Bowie - Under Pressure (Live) 1996 • TopPop 04:07
  • Chumbawamba - Tubthumping 03:34
  • ZZ Top - La Grange (Live From Gruene Hall) | Stages 04:38
  • Exmagma - Goldball   1974  (full album) 35:06
  • Digital News Report 2023 | Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism 02:20
  • Let 'Em Sing 04:31
View all videos

Popular

  • CLASS WAR: America’s Privileged Technocrats Not Ready For What’s About To Happen To Them | Jon Schwarz
  • How To Stop And Reverse Global Warming | Bing
  • Meaning Of Solidarity In The Time Of A New Palestine | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Federal Debt Trap: Issues and Possible Solutions | Ellen Brown
  • US and Israel: Is the ‘Unbreakable Bond’ Finally Breaking? | Ramzy Baroud

Blogs & Submissions

  • Ghosts of the Past: For Israel, War on UNESCO is an Existential Battle | Ramzy Baroud
  • Israeli ‘Coup’ and the Death of False Democracy | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Other Side of the West Africa Upheaval | Ramzy Baroud
  • ‘Bread and Circuses’: Musk, Zuckerberg and the Art of Distraction | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Twisted Israeli Logic of Murdering Palestinian Children, and What Can We Do to Stop It? | Ramzy ...
How To Stop And Reverse Global Warming | Bing
How To Stop And Reverse Global Warming | Bing
US and Israel: Is the ‘Unbreakable Bond’ Finally Breaking? ...
US and Israel: Is the ‘Unbreakable Bond’ Finally Breaking? | Ramzy Baroud
Meaning Of Solidarity In The Time Of A New Palestine | ...
Meaning Of Solidarity In The Time Of A New Palestine | Ramzy Baroud
CLASS WAR: America’s Privileged Technocrats Not Ready For ...
CLASS WAR: America’s Privileged Technocrats Not Ready For What’s About To Happen To Them | Jon Schwarz
The Federal Debt Trap: Issues and Possible Solutions | ...
The Federal Debt Trap: Issues and Possible Solutions | Ellen Brown
Prophets of Doom: Kissinger and the ‘Intellectual’ Decline ...
Prophets of Doom: Kissinger and the ‘Intellectual’ Decline of the West | Ramzy Baroud
Why US Democrats Are Growingly Challenging Israel | Ramzy ...
Why US Democrats Are Growingly Challenging Israel | Ramzy Baroud
The Financial Transactions Tax That Could Eliminate Need ...
The Financial Transactions Tax That Could Eliminate Need for All Others | Ellen Brown

Electronic Frontier Foundation

  • EFF's Comment to the Meta Oversight Board on Polish Anti-Trans Facebook Post 
    September 27, 2023
  • EFF, ACLU and 59 Other Organizations Demand Congress Protect Digital Privacy and Free Speech
    September 26, 2023
  • EFF at FIFAfrica 2023
    September 25, 2023
  • Digital Rights Updates with EFFector 35.12
    September 25, 2023

The Intercept

  • Atlanta Mayor Dismisses Cop City Referendum as “Not an Election”
    September 27, 2023
  • Menendez Indictment Looks Like Egypt Recruiting Intelligence Source, Say Former CIA Officials
    September 27, 2023
  • A Ukrainian Woman Protected Her Daughter From Russian Soldiers — and Was Accused of Collaborating With the Enemy
    September 27, 2023
  • The Hunt for the Nord Stream Bombers
    September 27, 2023

VTDigger

  • OneCare Vermont is successfully driving down health care costs
    September 27, 2023
  • Outdoor Gear Exchange to open new Essex store, reduce size of Burlington flagship
    September 27, 2023
  • Residents of a Colchester manufactured home park organize to form Vermont’s first new village in years
    September 27, 2023
  • Phil Scott requests federal disaster declaration for early August flooding in Addison and Rutland counties
    September 27, 2023

Mountain Times -- Central Vermont

  • Mountain Meditation: Connecting with Mother Nature and her creatures
    September 27, 2023
  • Livin’ the Dream: A better way to get there
    September 27, 2023
  • The Movie Diary: Running into trouble
    September 27, 2023
  • The Outside Story: Why do some mushrooms glow in the dark?
    September 27, 2023
  1. You are here:  
  2. Home
  3. All Content
  4. Edited
  5. Imagining Palestine: On Barghouti, Darwish, Kanafani and the Language of Exile | Ramzy Baroud
Copyright © 2023 World News Trust. All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU General Public License.